Nix Cleanup

Run cleanup and linting for this dendritic NixOS flake with awareness of repository-specific conventions and pattern conflicts.

This Repository's Cleanup Rules

Use Repository Lint Commands

This repository has custom lint infrastructure that respects exclusions:

Primary command: nix run .#lint

• Runs statix with --ignore '.agents/**'
• Runs deadnix with --exclude '.agents'
• Runs nixpkgs-fmt check
• Shows colored output with gum

Format command: nix run .#fmt

• Auto-formats all Nix files with nixpkgs-fmt
• Respects repository structure

Pre-commit hook: Automatically installed in dev shell

• Runs on git commit
• Formats staged files
• Runs full lint check
• Prevents commit if lints fail

Files and Directories to Skip

Always excluded (configured in lint scripts):

• .agents/skills/** - Template code with placeholders like <SERVICE-NAME>
• Files with intentionally invalid Nix for demonstration

Review carefully before touching:

• modules/flake-parts/host-configurations.nix - Host collector, module resolution may be intentional
• modules/flake-parts/lib.nix - Helper functions used by loader
• Files prefixed with _ - Work-in-progress code intentionally not imported
• secrets/ - Never lint or modify secrets

Dendritic Pattern vs Linter Conflicts

Statix and deadnix don't understand the dendritic pattern. Here's how to resolve conflicts:

Conflict 1: Enable Options

Statix suggests:

# Statix: "Consider using mkEnableOption"
options.myFeature.enable = lib.mkEnableOption "myFeature";
config = lib.mkIf cfg.enable { ... };

Dendritic pattern requires: Import-to-enable (no enable options)

# Correct dendritic pattern
flake.modules.nixos.myFeature = {
  services.myFeature.enable = true;  # Enabled by default
};

Resolution: REJECT statix suggestion. Modules in this repo are correct.

Exception: Containerized services (in services/containers/) conventionally use enable options due to heavier lifecycle management.

Conflict 2: Manual Inherit

Statix suggests: Removing "manual inherit" in loader files

Dendritic loaders need: Explicit inherit for clarity in import resolution

Resolution:

• Skip statix fix in modules/flake-parts/ directory
• Or use: statix fix --ignore manual_inherit

Conflict 3: Unused Arguments

Deadnix flags: Unused inputs or config arguments

Dendritic modules often need: These for future extensibility or flake-parts structure

Resolution:

• In loader files (flake-parts/): Keep arguments, they're infrastructure
• In feature modules: Safe to remove if truly unused
• Use _ prefix for intentionally unused: { _config, lib, ... }: ...

Conflict 4: Repeated Keys

Statix flags: Multiple definitions of same attribute

Collector pattern uses: Same aspect name across files (configs merge)

Resolution: This is correct! Collector pattern intentionally defines same name in multiple files.

• Example: flake.modules.nixos.syncthing defined in base module AND each host
• Configs merge via lib.mkMerge automatically

Flake Check Error Patterns

When nix flake check fails, diagnose the pattern:

"infinite recursion detected"

Likely cause: Conditional imports (dendritic anti-pattern)

Example:

# ❌ Causes infinite recursion
imports = lib.mkIf someCondition [ someModule ];

Fix: Load dendritic-pattern skill to diagnose and fix conditional import issues

"attribute 'X' already defined"

Likely cause: Collector pattern conflict without lib.mkDefault

Example:

# Two modules define same value without merge strategy
# Module A: services.myapp.port = 8080;
# Module B: services.myapp.port = 9090;

Fix: Base module should use lib.mkDefault, host overrides without

"attribute 'X' missing" or "option does not exist"

Likely cause: Cross-class import (nixos → darwin or vice versa)

Example:

# ❌ Importing NixOS module into Darwin context
flake.modules.darwin.myFeature = {
  imports = [ config.flake.modules.nixos.someFeature ];
};

Fix: Extract shared code to generic class, import generic into both

"expecting lambda" or type errors in loader

Likely cause: Malformed flake-parts module

Fix: Check module exports flake.modules.<class>.<name> correctly

Auto-Fix Decision Tree

Safe to Auto-Apply

These fixes are safe in this repository:

✅ Empty let blocks

• Statix: Remove unused let bindings
• Safe everywhere

✅ Formatting

• nix run .#fmt
• Safe everywhere, pre-commit handles this

✅ Legacy syntax

• rec { ... } → separate let binding
• Safe in feature modules (review in loaders)

Requires Review Before Fixing

⚠️ Anything in modules/flake-parts/

• Loader infrastructure is delicate
• Manual imports may be intentional for debugging

⚠️ Unused function arguments

• In loaders: Often needed for flake-parts structure
• In modules: Check if part of dendritic signature

⚠️ Suggestions to add options

• Especially mkEnableOption suggestions
• May contradict import-to-enable pattern

⚠️ Changes to imports

• Critical for dendritic wiring
• Never auto-fix without understanding impact

⚠️ lib.mkIf/lib.mkMerge changes

• Affects conditional logic and merging
• Can break collector patterns

Never Auto-Fix

❌ Files with # statix: ignore comments ❌ Template files (already excluded) ❌ Secrets directory ❌ Host hardware-configuration.nix (generated by nixos-generate-config)

Cleanup Workflow

1. Run Lint Check

nix run .#lint

Review output and categorize:

• Count errors by type
• Identify which are safe vs need review
• Check if any conflict with dendritic pattern

2. Analyze Conflicts

For each error, ask:

• Is this a dendritic pattern conflict? (enable options, collector pattern, etc.)
• Is this in a loader file? (needs extra care)
• Is this safe to auto-fix per decision tree?

3. Get Approval

Present findings:

Found 15 issues:
  - 8 safe fixes (formatting, empty let blocks)
  - 5 enable option suggestions (REJECT - dendritic conflict)
  - 2 unused arguments in loader (KEEP - infrastructure)

Auto-apply 8 safe fixes?

4. Apply Fixes

For safe fixes:

nix run .#fmt  # Format
# Manual fixes for specific issues

For statix fixes (carefully):

# Review each fix before applying
statix fix --ignore '.agents/**' <specific-file>

For deadnix (carefully):

# Only in non-loader files
deadnix -e --exclude '.agents' <specific-file>

5. Re-run Checks

nix run .#lint
nix flake check --no-build  # Verify no eval errors

6. Report Results

Summary of:

• Fixes applied
• Issues rejected (with reason)
• Remaining issues requiring manual attention

NEVER Do When Running Cleanup

NEVER auto-apply mkEnableOption suggestions

# ❌ Statix suggests this - REJECT IT
options.myFeature.enable = lib.mkEnableOption "myFeature";
config = lib.mkIf cfg.enable { ... };

# ✅ Dendritic pattern (correct for this repo)
flake.modules.nixos.myFeature = {
  services.myFeature.enable = true;  # Import-to-enable
};

Why: Breaks dendritic import-to-enable pattern. Features activate via imports, not enable options (except containers).

---

NEVER run cleanup on template files

# ❌ WRONG
statix fix .agents/skills/flake-module-creator/assets/

Why: Templates contain placeholders like <SERVICE-NAME> which are intentionally invalid Nix syntax. Already excluded via --ignore '.agents/**'.

---

NEVER auto-fix loader files without careful review

Files requiring extra care:

• modules/flake-parts/host-configurations.nix
• modules/flake-parts/lib.nix
• modules/flake-parts/meta.nix

Why: Central infrastructure. Manual imports, explicit inherits, and unused arguments may be intentional for:

• Debugging import resolution
• Future extensibility
• Flake-parts module signature

Breaking loader breaks entire flake.

---

NEVER ignore flake check failures

# ❌ WRONG - Suppressing without diagnosis
# (just run fmt and ignore flake check errors)

Why: nix flake check catches:

• Infinite recursion (conditional imports)
• Missing options (cross-class imports)
• Type errors (malformed modules)

These indicate dendritic pattern violations. Fix root cause, don't suppress.

---

NEVER modify dotfile-managed program configs

See docs/agents/dotfiles-policy.md for complete list.

Programs managed in ~/dotfiles (never configure here):

• Shell: Fish, Zsh, Bash
• Editors: Neovim, VSCode/Cursor
• Terminal: Kitty, Foot, WezTerm
• Desktop: Hyprland, Waybar, Rofi, etc.
• CLI tools: Bat, Btop, Lazygit, etc.

Why: Configuration lives in separate dotfiles repo. NixOS only installs packages, never configures these programs.

---

NEVER apply fixes that change imports without understanding impact

# ❌ DANGEROUS - Removing "unused" import
imports = [
  # config.flake.modules.nixos.baseModule  # Statix: unused?
];

Why: Imports are the dendritic wiring. Removing imports can:

• Break feature composition
• Lose collector pattern contributions
• Break multi-context module includes

Always verify import is truly unused by checking what it provides.

---

NEVER fix "repeated keys" in collector patterns

# Multiple files define same aspect - THIS IS CORRECT
# modules/services/syncthing.nix
flake.modules.nixos.syncthing = { ... };

# modules/hosts/host1.nix - SAME NAME, intentional
flake.modules.nixos.syncthing = { ... };

Why: Collector pattern intentionally uses same aspect name across files. Configs merge automatically via lib.mkMerge. Statix flags this as error but it's correct dendritic pattern.

Reference Documentation

When cleanup reveals dendritic pattern issues:

• Load ../dendritic-pattern/SKILL.md - For pattern validation and diagnosis
• Load ../flake-module-creator/SKILL.md - If creating new modules to fix issues
• Read docs/agents/dotfiles-policy.md - For dotfile-managed program list

Safety Guidelines

• Ask before applying fixes that touch imports, options, or loader files
• Present summary of findings before auto-fixing anything
• Report dendritic pattern conflicts explicitly
• When uncertain, load dendritic-pattern skill for validation
• Never modify secrets or hardware-configuration.nix